"The first time I had my middle school students leave comments on my blog, they were told to answer in complete sentences. I even gave them a handout with the questions they were answering. As long as they submitting something that looked something…"
Charting the Course of Teaching and Learning in a Networked World
Melissa Smith's Discussions
Perfecting Student Blog Comments
Started this discussion. Last reply by Enrique Guevarra Apr 27, 2009. 9 Replies 0 Likes
Melissa Smith's Page
Latest Activity
Kathy Subin replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments"I doubt I would continue with an exercise that my students were feeling bored with. I'd hope to find a way to get them engaged in the process then reintroduce it when they are more pumped about the process.
And yes, there is a lot of evidence…"
Melissa Smith replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments"Sorry - didn't mean to ignore the questions. They are in 6th grade, in a regular classroom. I think that most likely the students are just unmotivated about the material being discussed on the blog and don't like the fashion that the blog…"
Melissa Smith replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments"I love your point - to take it to the positive approach. Support the ideas and continue the conversation by allowing comments to go up, but positively reinforce those who are writing well.
I really feel too that if you get your blog an audience…"
Kathy Subin replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments"A few questions pop to mind... how old are these students? Is this an inclusive classroom, a remedial situation, AP?
Last, yes, if the purpose is just to blog and converse and contribute thoughts, becoming engaged in discussing with classmates,…"
Stephanie Clarkson replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments""Her argument is that the student is a representative of the school so he should have a good, well written response."
and a reflection on her abilities as a teacher, hmm? Is it entirely selfless that she's editing like this?
If…"
Kathy Subin replied to Melissa Smith's discussion Perfecting Student Blog Comments"How about having the students submit their comment (with reference to what thread they are replying to) in Word (or even email) format for editting. Teacher can turn on the show editting feature and return it to the student for corrections. Once…"
Melissa Smith posted a discussionPerfecting Student Blog Comments
We are at the beginning stages of implementing blogs at my school and a question has come up on what teachers are to do or react to student's comments having grammar and spelling errors, and maybe not enough "thought" given to their statement. I have one teacher who posted 4 questions - kind of open ended questions - this year. She has killed herself with the hours of not allowing comments to be posted. Her argument is that the student is a representative of the school so he should have a good,…See More
Profile Information
- School / Work Affiliation
- Presbyterian Day School
- Website
- http://www.pdsmemphis.org
- Skype, Twitter, or Other Accounts
- msmithpds
Comment Wall
- No comments yet!
Reviews
"The depth of your observations from last night is still resonating with me. I'm trying to think of another interview I've given where the questioner understood the material so well that he/she so regularly (and fluidly) went into new intellectual territory. I can't think of any. Pretty amazing. Thank you."
-David Shenk
"Steve is one of the most influential yet understated individuals in the world of Education. He gives thought leaders a widely attended global platform to voice their ideas to transform Education, and he does so with tremendous respect and intelligence."
-Charles Fadel
"Steve conducted the most in-depth interview I've ever been through and I enjoyed it to boot!"
-Doc Searls
"Steve is the Oprah of education."
-Monika Hardy's Students
"The nicest guy in ed tech."
-Rushton Hurley
"Steve is a national treasure."
-Leonard Waks
"Steve Hargadon is one of the most important change-makers of our time!"
-Connie Weber
More:
The Future of Education is a free series.You can support the interviews by using our Amazon link:
You can also support the site by making a donation (any amount):
Badge
About
Recognition
Thanks to:
Event Series Partners
© 2013 Created by Steve Hargadon.
Powered by
